There are Purina One reviews that indicate customers are happy with the product while others are a little more disparaging with some serious allegations. The brand has been around for 80 years and has spent a lot of time and money researching the best formulas and ingredients, which is how they’ve built their reputation. Recently, however, questions have been raised with regards to the quality, which begs the question: is Purina One a good dog food?
The answer isn’t a simple one because while the brand has its advocates that swear by the product, there are concerns with regards to the ingredients, the recalls and customers complaining about their dogs have bad—sometimes fatal—reactions to it.
Reputable websites give Purina One products high scores, as much as 5 out of 5 stars, and there are those that give it one star. In order for us to give it the most honest rating, we looked at as many reviews as possible. The product is affordable, the brand is consistent but the quality is sometimes lacking, and we have to take into account those customers that claim the dog food resulted in their pets getting sick. For this reason, we give Purina One 3 out of 5 stars.
At a Glance: Our Choices for the Purina One Dog Food
- Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula
- Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Puppy Formula
- Purina ONE SmartBlend Healthy Puppy Formula
- Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Adult Formula
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula|
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Puppy Formula|
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Healthy Puppy Formula|
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Adult Formula|
*Note: The links in the table above, as well as several links in the remainder of the article below, will take you to over to Chewy.com where you can find out more information about the products, such as current prices and customer reviews.
For some, the ingredients are questionable and they consider it to be below average in terms of quality. And then there are customers who rave about the product’s nutritional value, the additional supplements and that there are no poultry by-products. They even report their dogs are healthier since eating Purina One. It’s not easy to establish whether Purina One is a good dog food from customer reviews alone and it’s clear the jury is out on this particular product.
Purina One makes age-specific food, which means they consider what dogs need at different stages in their lives. For example, their formulas for senior dogs have glucosamine, a supplement known to help with the aging process.
There’s no doubt one of the biggest reasons Purina One is so popular is its affordable price point. There are a lot of brands with quality ingredients but they’re not always in everyone’s budget.
Primary Ingredient is Meat
As far as dog food brands that can be bought in the grocery aisle, this is one of the very few that has real meat has its primary or first ingredient. When compared to other similarly priced dog foods, this is a real advantage for Purina One.
Purina One scores serious points for its low price and because real meat is the first ingredient. But they lose a few because of the meat by-products, soybean, corn, and wheat meal are used, which are considered fillers.
There is no ignoring the negative reviews and the recalls. Some dogs have had bad reactions to the food, which could be due to a combination of sensitive stomachs and the by-products. Our suggestion is to monitor your dog’s progress on the food and be aware of any adverse reactions.
Purina changed its formula in recent years and it seems dogs preferred the old one.
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula||Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Puppy Formula|
|Purina ONE SmartBlend Healthy Puppy Formula||Purina ONE SmartBlend Large Breed Adult Formula|
Have a quick look at this review
A closer look at Purina One ingredients that they use by-products but they do use real meat as the first ingredients. There are people who also avoid it because there are no probiotics, chelated minerals, or amino acids. According to them, the low price doesn’t make up for the poor quality.
There is also a serious concern with regards to the average amounts fat and protein used in the recipes. Both amounts are lower or average in comparison to other dog foods and with one of the key ingredients being a poultry by-product meal, there are other affordable dog food brands that offer more of a well-balanced diet.
List of Purina Recalls
There have been recalls on some of the Purina brands, which is cause for concern.
In 2016 there was a voluntary recall on Beneful and Purina Pro Plan wet foods due to inadequate minerals and vitamins.
And in 2013 they did a recall on Purina ONE beyOnd’s White Meat Chicken & Whole Barley Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food due because of possible salmonella risk.
Purina One is a well-known dog food and has maintained a decent reputation over the years. Unfortunately, recalls and negative reviews have had a negative impact on the brand; however, there are still customers that love it and so do their dogs. In general, the reviews are mixed and depending on who you ask, you will get very different responses.
The change in the recipe has also had an effect where dogs that enjoyed the taste in the past no longer do. Would we give our pets Purina One? If budget was a concern, yes we probably would but we would definitely include a supplement to make sure they’re getting all the nutrition they need. We would also look out for any adverse reactions to the food. We would suggest you also read as many Purina puppy food reviews as possible.