Best Dog Toys for Pit Bulls (2023’s Top 5 Picks)

Best Toys for Pit Bulls

So, you're searching around for the best dog toys for Pit Bulls and want to be sure that you made the right decision before spending your money on something your furry buddy won't end up destroying only a few days later?

Don't worry, you're right where you need to be.

Our List Of Top 5 Dog Toys For Pitbulls
(Updated For 2023)




KONG Extreme Dog Toy
  • Safe 
  • You can stuff treats into the cavity
  • Durable and lasts longer than other toys
Nylabone Big Chew Durable Toy Bone for Large Breeds
  • Great option for large dogs
  • Low choke risk
  • Durable
Benebone Flavored Wishbone Chew Toy
  • Tastes like bacon
  • A bit flimsy
  • Could last up to 4 weeks
Nylabone Dura Chew Wishbone
  • Decent durability
  • Not quite safe for larger dogs
KONG Rubber Ball Extreme
  • Chew resistant -- lasts for weeks
  • Dogs can rest their head on it

*Note: The links in the table above, as well as several links in the remainder of the article below, will take you to over to where you can find out more information about the products, such as current prices and customer reviews.

Best Dog Toys For Pit Bulls

Pick #1 - KONG Extreme Dog Toy

KONG Extreme Dog Toy

Consistent #1 Pick For Us: We're always on the lookout for the safest, most high quality, durable dog toys for Pit Bulls to play around with.

Kong tops that list as our #1 choice almost every single time, as it does for many other dog owners out there.

Stuffable: If you even want to get a little bit creative, you can even stuff them with yummy Kong treats if your Pit won't give up on chewing.

Quick Word About Bad Smell: One word of caution though, a certain percentage of people have complained before that this toy tends to smell a little bad when it first arrives.

However, that's no big deal at all, as the bad smell will usually go away after 1-2 washes.

Either way, you were planning to wash the toy before you gave it to your Pitbull to put it in his/her mouth and chew on, weren't you?

Excellent Durable Option For Strong Pitbulls: Most Pit Bull owners swear by the Kong Extreme Dog Toy when it comes to long-lasting, chew-resistant toys, even though you can't expect it to last forever around your Pit.

Some report the toy lasting up to a few days (which is still impressive given the my-Pit's-toy-is-shredded-after-10-minutes standard), while others report the toy lasting up to a month, even under the mercy of Pitbulls weighing 70+ lbs!

Let's just say that you don't have to worry about buying a new toy every few days at least.

Different Sizes: For convenience purposes and to match the exact need of YOUR Pitbull, this toy comes in all sorts of sizes.

As you'll read in the "what makes the best dog toy for Pit Bulls" section below, size is a very important safety factor when it comes to ranking dog toys for Pit Bulls, because the last thing you want happening is your furry buddy swallowing one if it's too small.

Nylabone Big Chew Durable Toy Bone for Large Breeds

Excellent Option For Large Breeds: If you've got a large Pit Bull that weighs more than 50 lbs, then you can't go wrong with this dog toy.

These are MONSTROUS toys specifically designed for large and powerful Pitbulls.

One Of The Most Durable: Durability wise, this toy is one of the best you could come across, with many customers reporting that it's still in very good form even after a few weeks to a month's time has passed and countless bites and chews incurred, with nothing but a few tooth-marks here and there to show for.

Low Swallowing/Choking Risk: The risk of your Pitbull swallowing and choking on this one is very minimal as well, due to its design and size that makes it almost impossible for a Pitbull to gulp down.

It is a somewhat heavy dog toy though, so expect a few thumps and bangs here and there when your Pitbull drops it on the floor every now and then.

Closest As Possible To Real Bacon: Bacon isn't exactly a food you want to be feeding your Pitbull (or any other dog breed for that matter), but you can sure give your Pit a taste of some bacon with the Benebone Bacon Flavored Wishbone Chew Toy!

It's got an awesome, unique design to it as well (hint, hint: it's in the name! "Wishbone").

Connector: One feature we love with this toy is that because there's a connector between 2 bones (the left and right side bones), your PitBull can continue to play with the 2 bones even if it chews off/destroys/rips apart the connector.

One toy actually becomes two toy bones, without the choking hazard as well.

Not The Most Durable: You will have to be careful about how much time you allow your Pitbull to chew on this toy though because if it keeps at it all day long, it won't be lasting you that much.

Limit play time with this toy for a couple of hours a day and you can expect to have a toy that could last you up to a solid 4 weeks.

Nylabone Dura Chew Wishbone

Decent Durability: Just like our other top 3 picks, this toy's another top pick if you're looking for something that'll last more than a few weeks, even if your Pitbull's a real hard chewer and plays rough with it each and every day.

With time, you can expect your Pitbull's chews to start to take their tolls on this toy's sides bit by bit, but it will last you a good amount of time before you have to worry about replacing it.

When it starts to wear out, some sides can begin to get a little bit sharp and pointy, so you're going to have to pay extra attention to that and make sure that you replace it in due time before your Pitbull hurts itself with it.

Not The Safest For Large Sized Pitbulls: As far as size is concerned, this toy is somewhat smaller than our first 3 picks, so you might not want to go with this choice if you're looking for something large in size in order to limit the swallowing/choking risk often involved with these dog toys.

KONG Rubber Ball Extreme

More Than Just A Dog Toy: Not only is this a toy your Pit can have fun with day in, day out for a relatively long period of time before it wears out, it's also something your Pitbull can rest its head on when its tired and even sometimes sleep on.

This ball could really become your Pit's new best friend, no kidding.

Durable Enough: It will eventually wear out, much depending on the severity of your Pitbull's bites and how much time it plays with the toy every day, but it should be a good few weeks before you start to notice tooth marks and your Pitbull starts to snatch little pieces off of it.

Chew Resistant (To A Certain Extent): The ball's solid rubber structure also plays a very vital role in not allowing your Pitbull to chew on it full-force, as your dog will often times try to put the whole thing in his/her mouth before chewing, but the ball will often slip out because of the saliva.

Be Careful With Sizes: To eliminate the chances of your Pitbull swallowing this toy, you're going to want to stick to the larger size just to be on the safe side.

What Makes The Best Dog Toy For Pit Bulls?

Pitbull puppy

When it comes to buying dog toys for Pit Bulls, you're going to have to look for the most resistant of toys, because Pit Bulls are notorious for destroying anything giving to them to play with.

Yup, the thing your American Pit Bull Terrier actually loves to do more than play around with the toy is to destroy it and shred it down into pieces. Some of it is done for having a bit of fun while another part of it is done to let out some of that built-up energy inside.

And, if you've ever gotten a toy for your Pitbull before, no matter what material it was made of, you know first hand what we're talking about here.

Frankly speaking, it doesn't even take the most fierce chewing dog-breed to destroy some toys being produced out there, mainly because of how poorly manufactured these toys are. If you're lucky, the toy will last you till the end of the day after you bring it home.

And, well, unless you like to keep spending money and buying toys for your Pit every 2-3 days, you've got to be picky about the toys you buy for your Pit bull.

So, what factors exactly decide which toys are dubbed "the best dog toys for Pit Bulls"?

Chew resistant: No dog toy out there is a 100% chew-proof, but certain manufacturers put a lot more time, thought and resources (like long-lasting, high quality rubber) into this issue than others.

And, obviously, if a toy is going to be labeled as the best dog toy for Pit Bulls, it's going to have to be able to withstand the fiercest of chews and bites from your Pit Bull, to the extent that your Pit gives up trying to rip that thing apart and the toy emerges victorious.

Okay, it's not really a fight between your Pit Bull and the toy itself here, but you get my point. Moving on ...


Size: The best dog toys for Pit Bulls will take size into consideration and will be very carefully manufactured as to never allow even the slightest chance of your Pit Bull swallowing the toy while they're chewing it.

The manufacturers of the highest quality toys for Pit Bulls know for a fact that if a Pitbull (or any other dog for that matter) swallows a toy, this could very well lead to choking, blockage of the intestine, organ failure and death.

So, generally speaking, the larger the dog toy for your Pitbull, the less chances there are of your buddy swallowing the toy.

Material: Besides the size of the toy, which is a very important factor in deciding whether it's safe or not for the Pit Bull to play around with, the material that the toy is made up of itself plays a very big role as well.

The last thing you want is your dog playing with a toy made up of sharp edges or certain materials that could lead to physical pain and injuries sustained by your Pit.

The toy should be soft enough for your Pitbull to play around freely with without you having to worry about it coming back to you with a cut or wound.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

I accept the Privacy Policy